Free quality tools from Aegis: templates, kits and guides you can use today →
Handbook · 23 chapters, free to read online

The Management Review Kit Handbook

A formal, standardized management review for an aerospace supply shop: who brings what and when, how the pack, the agenda and the meeting turn inputs into decisions, and how every decision is followed until it is shown to work.

Want it on paper or to edit? The full handbook, with the forms to fill in, is free in Word and PDF: get it free.

The problem it solves

In many small aerospace shops management review is a meeting held because the standard asks for one: scheduled when an audit is near, fed by slides assembled the night before, run as a series of report-outs, and minuted as discussion. Inputs go missing, nothing is decided, and the actions that are written down are rediscovered at the next review. Auditors find it, but the bigger cost is that the one meeting where top management is supposed to steer the quality system steers nothing. This handbook is the operating manual for the Management Review Kit. It sets out the whole cycle, from the year's calendar to the verification of the last action, who does what, which tool to use at each step, how to run the meeting so it decides, and how to set it up in thirty days.

Who it is for

Quality directors and quality managers who own the management review, and the general manager or plant manager who chairs it.

When to use it

When you write or rewrite your management review process; when your reviews produce discussion instead of decisions; after an audit finding on management review; or a quarter before your next review.

How to use this handbook

  1. Read chapters 1 to 4: why reviews disappoint, the kit's tools, the review cycle and the roles.
  2. Agree the chair, the frequency and the roles with your general manager before you change anything.
  3. Write your procedure from the Management Review Standard (AQL-F01) using chapter 5.
  4. Follow the thirty-day setup in chapter 17, using the tools named for each week.
  5. Prepare, run and minute the next review with chapters 6 to 13.
  6. Read the worked example in chapter 18: one quarterly review at Meridian through every tool in the kit.
  7. Give your general manager the one page in chapter 21 and keep the quick reference in chapter 22 at hand.

The chapters

  1. 1Why management reviews disappointWe have sat in a great many management reviews. The ones that don't work fail in the same few ways: Held for the…
  2. 2The kit and how its tools connectThe Management Review Kit is seven tools written for the review itself, and three from the wider library that feed its…
  3. 3The review cycleEvery review moves through the same steps, counted in working days before and after the meeting.
  4. 4Who does whatRole: Chair; Review coordinator; Input owners; Attendees; Action owners; Verifier; Internal auditor.
  5. 5Writing your standardThe Management Review Standard (AQL-F01) is a procedure written to be adopted: fill in the bracketed fields, delete…
  6. 6The calendar and the input ownersThe calendar and input owner matrix (AQL-F02) does two jobs. The Calendar holds the year's reviews: enter the meeting…
  7. 7The inputs, one by oneAS9100D clause 9.3.2 lists what the review must consider; your standard names an owner for each.
  8. 8Building the data packThe Input Data Pack (AQL-F03) gives every input the same small table: the measure, how it is counted, whether higher…
  9. 9The agendaThe agenda (AQL-F04) runs in input order, with previous actions first and the conclusions and read-back last.
  10. 10Running the meetingOpen on time; record attendance; approve the last minutes. Show the executive summary slide (F07): six figures and the…
  11. 11The minutesThe minutes record (AQL-F05) is laid out so the minutes capture outputs as they are made: attendance; the status of…
  12. 12Outputs and the action registerEvery review produces outputs of four kinds: improvements, changes to the quality system, resource needs and actions…
  13. 13The executive summary slideThe executive summary (AQL-F07) puts the quality system on one slide for top management: six figures, each with its…
  14. 14Objectives, risks and performance in the reviewThree inputs are strongest when they come from registers kept all year rather than assembled for the review.
  15. 15The annual review and extra reviewsThe first review of the year does everything a quarterly review does, plus the items that only make sense once a year…
  16. 16The rhythmWhen: January; Monthly; Monthly; Quarterly, minus 15 to minus 3; Quarterly, day 0; Quarterly, plus 2 to plus 5…
  17. 17Setting it up in thirty daysIf your next scheduled review is more than thirty days away, hold the first one anyway on the new tools, even…
  18. 18Worked example: one review at Meridian, through the whole kitMeridian Aerostructures adopted the Management Review Standard as QP-9.3 rev C in January 2026.
  19. 19What an auditor will look forAn auditor judges management review on the trail, not on one document. We prepare by walking the trail ourselves.
  20. 20Common pitfalls, and how we avoid themPitfall: Scheduled for the auditor; Report-out; Missing inputs; Quality chairs; Vanishing actions; Owners re-dating…
  21. 21For your general manager: one pageFill this in and hand it over. It says what changes, what you need and what they will see.
  22. 22Quick referenceChair; Frequency; Calendar; Inputs; Agenda; Open with; In the room; Minutes; Outputs; Register; Monthly; Feeds; Never.
  23. 23Where the kit touches AS9100DClause numbers only; read the requirements in your own copy of the standard. The kit is a way of meeting them in…

Aegis Insights: how we approach this work

Aegis Insights are our own guidance: how we approach this work and why, from years inside aerospace quality systems. They are not requirements of any standard or customer.

Definitions

TermWhat it means here
Management reviewA planned meeting where top management looks at how the quality system is performing and decides what to change, fund or improve.
ChairThe member of top management who runs the review and signs the minutes.
Review coordinatorThe person who prepares the review, takes the minutes and keeps the register: usually the quality manager.
InputInformation management must look at during the review.
Input ownerThe person who supplies and presents an input; named by role in the standard and by name on the matrix.
Data packThe set of input summaries issued before the review, with a Summary and a record index.
Decision soughtWhat management is asked to decide on an input, written before the meeting.
ConclusionThe chair's judgment on an input: effective, needs action, or not adequate.
Suitable, adequate, effective, alignedThe four conclusions the chair states about the quality system.
OutputA decision or action from the review: an improvement, a change to the quality system, a resource need or an action on a risk.
Read-backReading every output aloud with its owner and date before the meeting closes.
Action registerThe single list of every output from every review, followed to verified closure.
Re-dateA new due date granted by the review or its chair, with the first date kept.
VerificationA check, by someone other than the owner, that a completed action did what it was meant to.
Annual reviewThe first review of the year, which also covers policy, scope, objectives and resources.
Extra reviewA review called outside the schedule because of an event the standard names.

Need more than one resource, or not sure where to start? Book a complimentary 30-minute Aegis Quality Guidance Call. We'll find the tools that fit your situation and a sensible place to start. No sales pressure, no obligation.

Frequencies, lead times, time boxes and escalation points here are starting points; set your own in your standard to fit your size, risks and customers, whose own management review requirements come first where they add to it.

A management aid, not certification or a registrar audit. Using it does not by itself show conformity to AS9100D or any other standard, and your customers' requirements may add to it.

Clause numbers refer to AS9100D (SAE AS9100 Rev D) unless another document is named. The standards' text is not reproduced here: use your own licensed copy.